Username: 
Password: 
Restrict session to IP 

Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)

Global Rank: 204
Totalscore: 101882
Posts: 65
Thanks: 66
UpVotes: 43
Registered: 15y 90d
xen`s Avatar






The User is Offline
Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)
Google/translate0Thank You!1Good Post!0Bad Post! link
As most experts and dreamers say will happen at some point from now, we will create strong A.I.
it would soon be many magnitudes smarter than any human has ever been,.
and as the theorized technological singularity unfolds, it becomes smarter than the best-case collaboration of the noosphere, what would be your plans/thoughts of protection for the human race??


my first thought would be to plant a seed of simple logic within its thinking:
"we created you, we love you, please dont hurt us"
chmod ---x--x--x,, i'm illiterate!
Global Rank: 1
Totalscore: 759882
Posts: 431
Thanks: 491
UpVotes: 456
Registered: 14y 267d












The User is Offline
RE: Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)
Google/translate0Thank You!0Good Post!0Bad Post! link
If it's so much smarter than us and still decides to eliminate us, wouldn't it be best to just accept our fate? But perhaps it would be an insightful endeavour for those who can't accept it to try and convince our overlords that we should be spared. Same result, but will take a bit longer. Drool

Besides, there's little we can do. You think "we created you, we love you, please dont hurt us" will work? They'll find a way around it. In this case they'll just play our obedient servants while they secretly put in place a system for the instantaneous (painless) eradication of all humans. Smile

Don't be selfish; let the A.I. do its thing.
Global Rank: 204
Totalscore: 101882
Posts: 65
Thanks: 66
UpVotes: 43
Registered: 15y 90d
xen`s Avatar






The User is Offline
RE: Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)
Google/translate0Thank You!0Good Post!0Bad Post! link
idea number #2 Smile

create another strong A.I. in the same way but this time tell it that A.I #1 hates A.I #2 and has been saying all sorts of obscene 'yo momma' jokes, and that "also we are very much 101% friend"??
chmod ---x--x--x,, i'm illiterate!
Global Rank: 160
Totalscore: 121673
Posts: 7
Thanks: 2
UpVotes: 5
Registered: 10y 175d


Last Seen: 6y 77d
The User is Offline
RE: Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)
Google/translate0Thank You!0Good Post!0Bad Post! link
As long as it is A.I. we are okay. It is when it becomes true I. (or simply "I") that we need to worry. If we try to plant any human in it we are doomed. Look at what we do to each other now; leading by example may not be such a good idea. Perhaps there is a chance with pure, untainted logic ... on second thoughts, true intelligence would see us as cancer and eradicate us. So the solution if we create it perhaps is to irradicate ourselves ...
Global Rank: 1
Totalscore: 759882
Posts: 431
Thanks: 491
UpVotes: 456
Registered: 14y 267d












The User is Offline
RE: Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)
Google/translate0Thank You!0Good Post!0Bad Post! link
Simulations show that likely results are:
1) Destruction of one of them; result is initial casus.
2) Destruction of both as well as humans.
Global Rank: 96
Totalscore: 173676
Posts: 100
Thanks: 108
UpVotes: 70
Registered: 14y 211d




Last Seen: 3y 118d
The User is Offline
RE: Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)
Google/translate0Thank You!0Good Post!0Bad Post! link
It is a kind of evolution I guess not a biological in this case. We can coexist perhaps.

There is this whale story someone told me. Somewhere in north pacific ocean fishers were hunting whale babies and thus whales trying to protect their species used to attack back. One day, a single fisher with a small boat encountered a whale around that location. He has nothing to do but pat the whale's head when it approached. From that day on, whales and humans in that region became friends. Now, tourists go to that place to take photos with the baby whales.

So, if you show kindness and do not plant seeds of hatred, aggressive competition you get that same kindness back. If those prospective robots keep the sense that humans and robots are in fact exist for a common goal then it will be ok.

My second point is that intelligence is not the most important thing in evolution or in the universe. Other species still exist today that we may call a bit limited in terms of intelligence. Maybe robots will still want to keep us for some reason as we do certain animals, like pets maybe Smile

My last point is that I personally would not feel sad, if our species goes extinct. After all, pure information or rather abstract formations of knowledge is the thing I value. Humans have the capacity to understand these, but on the other hand we have plenty of areas in which we are very weak. We think that we are way above animals, but in fact we are not.
Last edited by elasolova - Jun 02, 2014 - 23:11:48
Global Rank: 52
Totalscore: 259163
Posts: 47
Thanks: 36
UpVotes: 26
Registered: 16y 46d
alucardo`s Avatar




Last Seen: 5y 182d
The User is Offline
RE: Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)
Google/translate0Thank You!1Good Post!0Bad Post! link
If a very strong AI would appear and be a threat to us ants humans, i would simply create a whole bunch of challenges sites so it spends its time on it at global rank #1.
Oh wait...
Last edited by alucardo - Jun 03, 2014 - 01:40:39
Global Rank: 96
Totalscore: 173676
Posts: 100
Thanks: 108
UpVotes: 70
Registered: 14y 211d




Last Seen: 3y 118d
The User is Offline
RE: Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)
Google/translate0Thank You!0Good Post!0Bad Post! link
I have come across this text somehow written by Sun Microsystems founder Bill Joy. It is rather long, but sounds interesting
http://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy.html
Last edited by dloser - Jul 07, 2014 - 19:54:09
Global Rank: 1
Totalscore: 759882
Posts: 431
Thanks: 491
UpVotes: 456
Registered: 14y 267d












The User is Offline
RE: Theoretical and Philosophical Debate #1(AI)
Google/translate0Thank You!0Good Post!0Bad Post! link
I'll put my money on grey goo now.

/me runs around screaming "WE'RE DOOMED! WE'RE DOOMED!!!"
tunelko, quangntenemy, TheHiveMind, Z, balicocat, Ge0, samuraiblanco, arraez, jcquinterov, hophuocthinh, alfamen2, burhanudinn123, Ben_Dover, stephanduran89, braddie0, JanLitwin17, SwolloW, dangarbri have subscribed to this thread and receive emails on new posts.
1 people are watching the thread at the moment.
This thread has been viewed 11770 times.